Dec 18, 2025 Leave a message

astm-b444-(1)-(1).pdf

Alloy 600 vs Alloy 625: Chemistry, Strength and Corrosion Comparison

Alloy 600 and alloy 625 are both nickel-based materials sold into high-temperature and corrosive service, but they are not interchangeable. Alloy 600 is a nickel-chromium-iron alloy that relies on a simple solid-solution structure, while alloy 625 adds substantial molybdenum and niobium, giving it markedly higher strength and a much wider corrosion envelope at a higher price per kilogram.

Chemistry Compared

Element Alloy 600 (UNS N06600) Alloy 625 (UNS N06625)
Nickel 72.0 min 58.0 min
Chromium 14.0-17.0 20.0-23.0
Iron 6.0-10.0 5.0 max
Molybdenum - 8.0-10.0
Niobium + tantalum - 3.15-4.15
Carbon 0.15 max 0.10 max (Grade 1)

The composition gap explains the behavioural gap. Chromium supplies oxidation resistance and keeps the passive film intact; molybdenum and niobium in 625 raise resistance to pitting, crevice attack and reducing acids, and niobium also contributes solid-solution strengthening that cannot be obtained in 600.

Strengthening Mechanism and Mechanical Data

Both grades are solid-solution alloys rather than precipitation-hardening alloys, so neither responds to an aging treatment in the way that 718 or X-750 does. Alloy 600 in the annealed condition is normally supplied to a minimum tensile strength of 550 MPa and a minimum 0.2 percent yield strength of 240 MPa. Alloy 625 Grade 1, solution annealed, is specified with a minimum tensile strength of 827 MPa and a minimum yield strength of 414 MPa, roughly fifty percent higher than 600 for the same product form. Where higher strength is required, 625 can be supplied in the cold-worked condition, but that reduces ductility and complicates forming.

Grade 1 and Grade 2 for Alloy 625

Alloy 625 is ordered in two conditions that differ only in the annealing treatment. Grade 1 has a minimum annealing temperature of 1600 °F (871 °C); Grade 2 has a minimum annealing temperature of 2000 °F (1093 °C). The higher-temperature anneal of Grade 2 produces a coarser grain structure and better creep behaviour, whereas Grade 1 is easier to bend and machine after delivery. The requirement must be stated on the purchase order because the two conditions are not interchangeable at the fabrication stage.

Corrosion and Temperature Limits

Alloy 600 tolerates oxidising and mildly reducing environments and is widely used in caustic service and in chloride-free high-purity water circuits, where its resistance to stress corrosion cracking is the main reason for selection. Alloy 625 goes further: it resists pitting and crevice corrosion in chloride-bearing and acidic media, and it handles seawater and mixed acid streams where 600 would fail. On the high-temperature side, 600 retains useful strength and oxidation resistance in furnaces and heat-treating equipment, and it has a slightly higher maximum usable metal temperature than 625, which is one of the few points where the cheaper alloy wins.

Product Forms and Specifications

Seamless pipe and tube: ASTM B167 for nickel-chromium-iron alloys including 600, and ASTM B444 for 625.

Welded pipe: ASTM B517 for the 600 family and ASTM B705 for 625; welded tube for 625 is covered by ASTM B704.

General requirements for seamless pipe and tube, including testing and tolerances, sit in ASTM B829.

Plate, sheet and strip: ASTM B168 for the 600 family and ASTM B443 for 625.

How to Choose

Choose 600 when the environment is oxidising or caustic, chlorides are controlled, and cost and fabricability dominate. Choose 625 when chlorides, seawater, pitting or reducing acids are present, when higher pressure ratings demand more strength, or when the same component must survive both corrosion and elevated temperature. For a mixed chloride and high-temperature duty, 625 is the safer engineering answer even though the material cost is higher.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Can alloy 600 be substituted for alloy 625?
A: Only after a corrosion review. The two alloys differ by 8.0-10.0 percent molybdenum, and 625 has roughly 50 percent higher minimum yield strength. In chloride or reducing-acid service a direct substitution of 600 for 625 will normally lead to premature failure.

Q: Is either alloy hardenable by heat treatment?
A: No. Both are solid-solution strengthened. Strength is controlled by cold work, not by aging. Alloys such as 718 and X-750 in the same nickel family are the ones that gain strength from a precipitation heat treatment.

Q: Which alloy has the higher maximum service temperature?
A: Alloy 600 has a slightly higher usable metal temperature and lower cost, while alloy 625 offers superior corrosion resistance and strength. The decision usually follows the corrosion environment rather than the temperature alone.

Q: Why does alloy 625 have Grade 1 and Grade 2?
A: The grades differ in minimum annealing temperature: 1600 °F (871 °C) for Grade 1 and 2000 °F (1093 °C) for Grade 2. Grade 2 is chosen for creep-limited service, Grade 1 for ease of subsequent forming and machining.

Q: How is alloy 625 identified on a mill certificate?
A: The certificate lists UNS N06625, the condition (Grade 1 or Grade 2), the applicable ASTM B444 or B705 specification, heat number, chemical analysis and the tensile and yield results from the tested lot.

Send Inquiry

whatsapp

Phone

E-mail

Inquiry