How to tell brass vs copper

1. Visual Inspection: Color and Luster

The most immediate difference between brass and copper is their color, as their alloy compositions create distinct hues:

Copper: A warm, distinct reddish-orange to salmon-pink color. Freshly polished copper has a bright, metallic sheen, but it tarnishes over time (exposed to air/moisture) to form a dull, dark brown or greenish patina (known as "verdigris"). This patina is a signature of pure or high-purity copper (e.g., copper pipes, pennies pre-1982 in the U.S.).

Brass: An alloy of copper and zinc (typically 60–70% copper, 30–40% zinc), so its color is yellow-gold to golden-brown. The exact shade depends on zinc content: higher zinc levels make it lighter (e.g., "yellow brass" with ~35% zinc is bright gold), while lower zinc levels give it a deeper, more coppery tint (e.g., "red brass" with ~15% zinc is a darker golden-brown). Brass tarnishes more slowly than copper, often developing a faint brown or gray patina rather than green.

Quick Tip: If the metal looks like a "dull gold" or "light bronze," it's likely brass. If it's reddish-orange (even when tarnished), it's copper.

2. Hardness Test: Scratch Resistance

Brass is significantly harder than pure copper due to the strengthening effect of zinc. You can test this with a sharp object (e.g., a nail, key, or metal file) or by bending a thin piece (if flexible):

Copper: Soft and malleable. A sharp object will easily scratch its surface, leaving a visible mark. Thin copper sheets (e.g., copper foil) can be bent repeatedly without cracking.

Brass: Harder and less malleable. Scratching it with the same object requires more force, and the scratch will be shallower or less distinct. Thin brass pieces (e.g., brass sheet metal) may bend once but are more likely to crack or resist further bending.

Caution: Avoid scratching valuable items-test an inconspicuous area (e.g., the back of a decorative piece) if possible.

3. Magnet Test: Magnetic Response

Neither pure copper nor standard brass is magnetic, but this test can still help rule out other metals (e.g., steel, iron-based alloys) that might be confused with brass. However, it won't distinguish brass from copper directly-use it alongside other tests:

Copper: Non-magnetic. A magnet (e.g., a refrigerator magnet) will not stick to it at all.

Brass: Non-magnetic (unless it contains small amounts of iron, which is rare in standard brass). A magnet will also not stick to brass.

Note: If a magnet sticks, the metal is likely not pure copper or brass-it may be a brass-plated steel or another alloy.

4. Weight Test: Density Comparison

Copper is denser than brass, so two pieces of the same size will have different weights:

Copper density: ~8.96 g/cm³

Brass density: ~8.4–8.7 g/cm³ (varies with zinc content; higher zinc = lower density)

info-450-444 info-448-442

info-448-442 info-444-440

5. Sound Test: Tonal Difference

When struck lightly, brass and copper produce distinct sounds due to differences in their elasticity:

Copper: Produces a dull, muted thud or low-pitched ring that fades quickly. This is because copper absorbs sound energy more easily.

Brass: Produces a bright, high-pitched ring that lasts longer (similar to a bell or cymbal). This "resonant" sound is why brass is used for musical instruments (e.g., trumpets, trombones) and bells.

How to do it: Tap the metal gently with a hard object (e.g., a spoon or hammer). Listen for the tone and how long it persists.

6. Chemical Test (For Confirmation, Use with Caution)

For a more definitive test (e.g., identifying old or tarnished pieces), use a mild acid (common household items work, but handle with care):

Materials needed: White vinegar (acetic acid) or lemon juice, a cotton swab, and gloves (to protect skin).

Procedure:

Rub a small area of the metal with the cotton swab dipped in vinegar/lemon juice to remove any surface tarnish.

Observe the reaction:

Copper: The cleaned area will reveal its bright reddish-orange color. Over time (minutes to hours), the exposed copper will start to re-tarnish, possibly developing a faint greenish tint (verdigris) as it reacts with the acid and air.

Brass: The cleaned area will show its golden-yellow color. Brass reacts more slowly with mild acids, so it will not re-tarnish quickly and will not develop a green tint (it may turn slightly brown instead).

Warning: Avoid using strong acids (e.g., hydrochloric acid) and test only on non-valuable or inconspicuous parts-acids can damage finishes.