Apr 10, 2024 Leave a message

How to Tell the Difference Between Nickel-Based Superalloys and Stainless Steel

The Basic Distinction Between the Two Families

Stainless steel is an iron-based alloy whose corrosion resistance comes from a chromium content of at least about 10.5%. The matrix remains iron, and the familiar austenitic grades contain roughly 8–10% nickel added to stabilise that structure. Nickel-based superalloys move the other way: the matrix itself is nickel, usually more than half of the alloy, with chromium, molybdenum, niobium, cobalt, aluminium and titanium added on top. The two families therefore perform differently at high temperature, in strong acids and in chloride media, and need different heat treatments.

Appearance will not separate them. Both can be bright, annealed and pickled, and both are non-magnetic in the common conditions, so a magnet is only a first screen.

Chemical Composition Compared

Composition ranges, in percentages by mass:

Grade Ni Cr Fe Mo Nb Other additions
600 about 72 14.0–17.0 6.0–10.0 - - Mn, Cu
617 44.2–56.0 20.0–24.0 up to 3 8.0–10.0 - Co, Al, Ti
625 about 58 20.0–23.0 up to 5 8.0–10.0 3.15–4.15 low carbon
690 about 59.5 about 30 about 9.2 - - low cobalt
718 50.0–55.0 17.0–21.0 balance 2.8–3.3 4.75–5.5 Al, Ti
X-750 about 70 14.0–17.0 5.0–9.0 - 0.7–1.2 Ti 2.25–2.75, Al

The contrast is clearest in the nickel column: a 304 or 316 type steel contains roughly 8–12% nickel with iron as the balance, whereas these grades are nickel-based.

Strengthening Mechanisms and Alloy Behaviour

Grade 600 is solid-solution strengthened, with good oxidation resistance and useful strength at moderate elevated temperature.

Grade 625 holds molybdenum and niobium in solid solution, giving acid resistance and excellent weldability; its low-cycle-fatigue variant serves thin-wall pipe.

Grade 690 combines high chromium with low cobalt and low resistivity and serves nuclear and high-purity duties.

Grade 718 is strengthened by a gamma-double-prime precipitate and welds and brazes well, while grade 751 and the gas-turbine casting grades rely on higher aluminium additions for rupture strength and hot corrosion resistance.

Equivalent Grade Designations

Grade Werkstoff No. UNS AFNOR JIS BS EN
600 2.4816 N06600 NC15FE11M NCF 600 NA 13 NiCr15Fe
601 2.4851 N06601 NC23FeA NCF 601 NA 49 NiCr23Fe
617 2.4663 N06617 - - - -
625 2.4856 N06625 NC22DNB4M NCF 625 NA 21 NiCr22Mo9Nb
690 2.4642 N06690 - - - -
725 not registered N07725 - - - -
X-750 2.4669 N07750 - - - -

Cross-reference tables circulate with transcription errors, and the same designation is sometimes listed against two grades, so entries should be confirmed from the material certificate.

Practical Identification in the Workshop

Chemical analysis. Handheld X-ray fluorescence identifies nickel, chromium, molybdenum and niobium within seconds and remains the only reliable positive test.

Magnetic response. Austenitic stainless steel is essentially non-magnetic while ferritic and martensitic grades are strongly magnetic, but nickel-based grades are also non-magnetic, so a magnet separates only some cases.

Density. The nickel-rich grades are denser, around 8.4–8.5 g/cm³ against 7.9–8.0 g/cm³ for a 304-type steel.

Documentation. The mill certificate and the plate markings remain the definitive evidence of grade.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: How can the two families be told apart on site?
A magnet and a density check separate them in many cases, but the reliable identification is chemical analysis backed by the mill certificate.

Q: Is a nickel-based alloy always non-magnetic?
In the annealed condition the common grades are essentially non-magnetic, as is austenitic stainless steel, so magnetism indicates the family only occasionally.

Q: Why are nickel-based grades preferred at high temperature?
Their nickel matrix stays stable without phase change and forms protective oxide scales, whereas stainless steel softens and scales far earlier.

Q: Can stainless steel be substituted for a nickel-based grade?
Only where temperature, chloride and acid concentration are all moderate; strong acids, high chlorides or sustained heat above 600 °C cause rapid failure.

Q: Why does the nickel-based grade cost more?
Nickel, molybdenum and niobium are expensive and processing demands tighter control, so the premium is justified only where the duty requires it.

Send Inquiry

whatsapp

Phone

E-mail

Inquiry